To be perfectly honest, I don't really care very much if someone rips off the pretty pictures I take of products and uses them for their eBay listings.
If you ask me for permission to use my pictures for commercial purposes, I'll cheerfully license them to you for a small fee.
But most people don't ask, of course. They just do a Google Images search and take whatever they want.
That doesn't actively take money out of my pocket. It just deprives me of royalties from someone who clearly doesn't want to pay royalties anyway. Which is why I don't very much care.
(Cue ISO Standard Piracy Argument in 3, 2, 1...)
Anyway, a little while ago, I reviewed a pen-shaped close-focus webcam thing called the ETime Home Endoscope. It's a neat gadget.
There aren't many pictures of the ETime Endoscope online, so if you image-search for it, you'll get a bunch of my pics on the first page of results.
This, and the absence of any decent handout pictures from the people who make the camera, has made my pictures pretty much the only option for someone who wants to sell ETime endoscopes on eBay or wherever but (a) can't be bothered taking their own pictures and (b) doesn't want to pay for someone else's pictures.
Since I'm now signed up with eBay's Verified Rights Owner ("VeRO") program, though, all I have to do to get eBay to delete any listings that copy my stuff is send them an e-mail. A couple of days later, the offending listings will be kaput.
So every now and then, when a reader points out a ripped-off listing to me or when I find one myself, I do that.
I did that with one seller of the Endoscope a while ago. Their listings disappeared, and they didn't post any more that I've noticed. Apparently taking pictures of the stuff they sell cuts into their profit margins too much to make it worthwhile, or something.
The other day, I found that another eBay seller, "endoscopes.endoscopy", was doing the same thing. They appear to be under the impression that putting their own advertising text on top of my picture, and/or sticking three of my pictures together with some others from the ETime site, is enough to make the pictures theirs.
Even as I was typing this, the above PhotoBucket-hosted image mysteriously disappeared. Clearly the work of someone who's quite sure that everything they're doing is perfectly above board!
I saved it, though. Here's the top portion of their composite image, which contains no pictorial content besides my images and ones from the ETime site.
Their PhotoBucket page at the moment still contains several versions of the composite image. From the text on the variants, it would seem they're also listed on eBay as "usb.etime.pencams". And here, here, here and here are their direct copies of my images, except with the aspect ratio screwed up and text slapped on top.
Oh, and apparently they don't like people copying images from their own site about hockey! It would appear that people "who steal all our photos and ideas" are "punk asswipes"!
Couldn't have put it better myself, guys!
I'm speculating, above, about how these people's reasoning works, because it's kind of hard to figure it out from this:
Date: Sat, 16 Feb 2008 15:36:42 -0500
From: "usbscopes@gmail.com" <usbscopes@gmail.com>
To: dan@dansdata.com
Subject: removing our ebay listingsDear Dan,
1) We don't appreciate you removing our ebay listings of e-time pencams off ebay!
2) We are an authorized ebay distributors of etime ehe pencams.
3) We didn't use any wording or images off your website!
4) If you have our listings removed again, We are hiring an attorney in Australia to take you into court. So please be prepared!
endoscopes.endoscopy
After sending me this, they listed another ten or so auctions with the same ripped-off pictures in them.
I told them the exact pictures they had copied, and that I took those pictures in my house, with my camera, for my review of the product. And I filed another VeRO complaint, and got all of the new listings pulled too.
Their cogent response:
Date: Sun, 17 Feb 2008 13:47:21 -0500
From: "Steven Jordan" <usbscopes@gmail.com>
To: Dan <dan@dansdata.com>
Subject: Re: removing our ebay listingssee you in court asshole
(...followed by the quoted text of my e-mail, which it seems did not make much of an impression upon them.)
I'm sure these guys are hopping on a plane from Florida right now. I'd better make some space on my calendar.
And yes, I'm aware that this could have been much, much funnier.
But I have to work with what I can get.